Judge in Dekraai Case to Decide Whether to Split Trial into 2 Phases

Judge Thomas Goethals says the guilt phase shouldn't last too long, one or two weeks. The proceedings could start June 9.

Police take Scott Dekraai into custody following the worst mass murder in Orange County history. Patch file photo.
Police take Scott Dekraai into custody following the worst mass murder in Orange County history. Patch file photo.


City News Service

An Orange County Superior Court judge today said he will decide next week whether to split the two phases of a trial of the man accused of carrying out the worst mass killing in Orange County history.

Orange County Superior Court Judge Thomas Goethals has been hearing testimony from a former jailhouse informant, known as Inmate F, in a bid by Scott Evans Dekraai's attorneys to have the Orange County District Attorney's Office removed from the case based on allegations that the prosecution misused jail snitches to collect evidence.

The defense attorneys also want Goethals to drop the death penalty as an option against Dekraai, who is accused of killing eight people at the Salon Meritage in Seal Beach.

Last month, Goethals raised the possibility of the rare separation of Dekraai's trial -- holding the so-called guilt phase first and the penalty phase with a separate jury later. Dekraai's trial had been scheduled to begin Monday, but the misconduct allegations have forced a delay.

A trial to determine Dekraai's guilt would not take much time, Goethals said. Dekraai's attorneys have said he is willing to plead guilty and receive a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole if prosecutors stop seeking the death penalty.

"Frankly, it seems to me that a guilt-phase trial wouldn't take more than week or two at most," Goethals said. "So, I'm thinking perhaps June the 9th (for the trial's start)."

If convicted, a separate jury could be called to consider whether Dekraai should be kept in prison for the rest of his life or be executed.

"Now we're not just floating the idea," Goethals said of the split death penalty trial. "It's a serious proposal and one I really like the sound of."

Prosecutors and defense attorneys will raise any concerns they have about splitting up the process on Monday morning. In the afternoon, Assistant District Attorney Dan Wagner will be called to testify about the gathering of evidence against Dekraai by Inmate F.

The informant finished testifying Thursday. Dekraai's attorney, Assistant Public Defender Scott Sanders, spent the bulk of the week grilling the one-time informant, who is now in federal witness protection, about how he gathered evidence against Dekraai, as well as against another defendant facing the death penalty and Mexican Mafia members in the county's jails.

Sanders filed a 500-plus page legal motion alleging prosecutors and sheriff's officials collected evidence in a way that violated the constitutional rights of Dekraai and others.

Inmate F testified today that he showed Dekraai how he could used a "shaved-down spoon," to hold open a sink spigot of warm water for bathing, known in inmate parlance as "birdbathing." A grateful Dekraai, who had been denied a shower for some time, called him a "magician," the informant testified.

Sanders questioned Inmate F about asking Dekraai what he discussed with his attorney, which would be a violation of the accused killer's rights. The informant said he "didn't really care" what Dekraai told his attorney and added, "it was none of my business."

Inmate F claimed Dekraai volunteered information about the Salon Meritage rampage.

Sanders asked him if it bothered him to "betray (Dekraai's) trust," by snitching on him to authorities.

"A little bit," he replied.

The informant claimed earlier he had an epiphany while he was in isolation in June 2010 that he wanted out of the gang life and soon after began cooperating with authorities.

Inmate F was a shot-caller for the Mexican Mafia and served on a committee of inmates that would recommend targets on hit-lists, called "hard candy" lists.

One of his "closest allies," Leonel Vega, wanted to put Deputy District Attorney Erik Petersen on a hard-candy list, Inmate F testified.

Vega, also known as "Downer," was the "right-hand man" of Armando "Mando" Moreno, who lost a power struggle for control of the Mexican Mafia with "The Old Man," Peter Ojeda, who authorities say still calls the shots from a federal prison. Inmate F also backed Moreno, he testified.

When Vega told Inmate F he was "pissed off at the DA and he was planning to kill him," the informant called his handlers, he testified.

"He even told me what kind of car he drove," he testified.

Petersen is also on Sanders' witness list and is expected to testify in the hearing. Goethals removed Petersen from a jail-beating case on Friday due to a finding that he improperly withheld evidence from defense attorneys.

Sanders also plans to have Senior Deputy District Attorney Matt Murphy testify. Murphy is prosecuting another Sanders client, Daniel Patrick Wozniak, who is charged with killing two people and dismembering one of his victims.

--City News Service

Joker Joe March 21, 2014 at 01:47 PM
There is no law against it. Let's see what Obama thinks? I know gay and lesbian marriage are sanctioned by him.
David March 22, 2014 at 05:26 AM
This INHUMAN thing is a PIECE OF GARBAGE. So, he wants life, and no death penalty? The innocents he killed did not get that choice, why should he? What does he have to live for anyways? Taxpayers should pay to keep him alive and well sustained? Fuck Him!
Wolfman March 22, 2014 at 08:01 PM
did he grow those boobs in prison and why in the cop touching them
Smokey Bear March 24, 2014 at 04:11 AM
He has man boobs, maybe that is why he is a psycho killer? He was probably picked on in gym class in school, oooh poor guy,,, not.... Death Penalty by hanging!!! Bring back the gallows!!!
S.A.P. March 25, 2014 at 11:33 AM
Hilarious comments! Never mind that this is the Seal Beach Patch, and the families and friends of the victims come here to get news, and will read your funny, funny comments about this murderer. As long as you get your jokes in, that's all that matters, right?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »