Swallows Day Parade May Not Go On

The City Council has demanded parade organizers change their policy of banning electric wheelchairs. They say they'll handle requests on a case-by-case basis. One councilman says that's not good enough.

The Swallows Day Parade may be cancelled unless the organizers behind it carry out a City Council mandate to allow participants in electric wheelchairs into the parade, said one San Juan Capistrano councilman.

“As of now, there will be no parade,” Councilman Derek Reeve said Friday.

The has for its first 53 years prohibited motorized vehicles of any kind, including electric wheelchairs. Organizers pride themselves on hosting one of the larger non-motorized parades in the country.

But , license and associated street closures unless the parade’s organizers, the Fiesta Association, changed its policy regarding electric wheelchairs.

Association members met Wednesday, said Jeff Schroeder, association publicity chairman, and decided to grant permission to one parade applicant, a man who appeared at the council meeting Tuesday, and, through his sister, Heidi Langefeld, asked to march in the parade as part of the Canine Companions for Independence drill team.

“The Fiesta board of directors and especially the parade chair (Ben Dixon), after having several verbal and email conversations with the sister of Herb, has determined that he does need his specialized chair to be mobile,” Schroeder said.

“We did offer several alternative suggestions, none of which was viable or acceptable," he added. "The board voted to accept this entrant and allow him to use his motorized wheelchair.”

But the decision is not in keeping with the letter or the spirit of the City Council’s decision, Reeve said.

“They are openly defying our elected City Council and placing us in an awkward position,” Reeve said. “While I remain optimistic the Fiesta Association will recognize they're fighting a losing battle and change this abhorrent policy, as of now, there will be no parade because of [their] inaction.”

Other City Council members and city personnel could not be reached for comment.

On Tuesday, Councilman Sam Allevato said: "By right, people with disabilities should be included in the parade." And Councilman John Taylor said, "I think the intent is that everybody should be able to participate."

The exact wording of the motion passed Tuesday was that the city would grant the parade permit, license and street closures “with the contingence that the Fiesta Association would remove their policy and allow the use of an electric  [wheelchair] if it is medically required."

Reeve, who himself is in an electric wheelchair, said he has tried to contact the Fiesta Association to correct the situation, but he has not received a response. He said he now plans to boycott all Fiesta Association events. The next event is this Sunday, the annual .

“Can you imagine if there was a ban on African-Americans for historical reasons, but they would give case-by-case exceptions?” Reeve said.

At the City Council meeting Tuesday, Fiesta Association representatives said one of the reasons for the wheelchair ban was the risk of scaring the horses in the parade. But Schroeder said that’s not actually the case.

“It was purely about the Swallows Parade 54-year tradition of being a non-motorized parade,” he said, “and, by the way, the city motto, which is ‘preserving the past, to enhance the future.’ ”

Schroeder said parade organizers are compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act because alternatives are sought for the wheelchair-bound.

“According to ADA regulations, one must offer different alternatives to the person for his or her mobility,” Schroeder said. “This is nothing new for us. We have had similar requests in the past, but have always had an alternative that was viable and acceptable for the person,” he said, adding that the portable toilets found along the parade route and at the Mercado fair after the parade are handicapped accessible.     

A representative of the ADA section of the Department of Justice declined to comment.

concerned parent March 01, 2012 at 01:03 AM
How sad that "tradition" trumps the rights of individuals in some minds. Do the parade organizers have any idea how narrow-minded this makes them look, at least to someone who's a neutral observer? (I don't live in SJC, I'm not disabled, and I don't know any of the parties involved.)
Donna Taylor March 01, 2012 at 01:08 AM
I wasn't going to comment further on this closed 'non-issue' but it seems that some continue to disregard the facts and go immediately to their own agenda. It was NEVER about not allowing "a disabled person the dignity of getting themselves down the street in a parade without having to be pushed by someone else." It was (and is) about the tradition and heritage of the Parade, which has NOTHING to do w/ any form of discrimination, unless you are a motor. As far as I can tell, the FA was (and remains) in hopes that any & all participants would respect and cherish the tradition of the Swallows Day celebration and the Parade, joining the others in the spirit of the event. It's too bad that in this case, that did not happen, but the law and individual rights are to be respected regardless of tradition so... they changed their Parade rules to make sure the 'non-motorized' rule wasn't specific to wheelchairs and welcomed this individual to participate in the Parade. That was sooo last week... Time to MOVE ON... I will again close w/ my same comment... Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.
Eric March 01, 2012 at 02:41 AM
Donna Taylor, I admire your thought pattern. The rest of you,too, but especially Donna.
Steve Behmerwohld March 01, 2012 at 03:01 AM
@ Penny, yes Ma'm.
SJCNative March 01, 2012 at 04:24 PM
I don't know who he/she sjcnative1 is. However, I do agree with his/her view points.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »