Charter School Teacher Accused of Forcing Noose Around Boy's Neck

The teacher is suspended, and the child's mom tells Patch there were other incidents. An attorney for the school says she's playing the race card.

Screenshot of Oxford Preparatory Academy's website.
Screenshot of Oxford Preparatory Academy's website.

Originally posted at 4:32 p.m. May 7, 2014. Edited to correct a figure, add a link.

By Penny Arévalo | Patch Editor

MISSION VIEJO, Calif. — A teacher at Oxford Preparatory Academy has been placed on leave while school administrators investigate whether she made racist gestures to the only African-American student in the class – including having a noose hung around his neck.

While the investigation is ongoing, a representative from the Mission Viejo-based charter school, Erika Schulte, said the teacher was put on administrative leave within 24 hours of the parent’s notification.

But Schulte and the boy’s mom, who gave an interview to Patch, have different accounts of what happened.

In the radio interview on KFI, Schulte characterized the incident as a one-time misunderstanding that was addressed quickly. The mother said it was one of several instances of potentially racist behavior, and that two initial conversations with the principal went nowhere.

The incident in question – or "the straw that broke the camel’s back," as the mother writes in an email to OPA and Capistrano Unified officials – took place on a recent field trip to Riley’s Farm, a working farm in Yucaipa that recreates historical events from the Civil War.

The mother said teacher Renee Schultz volunteered her son for a demonstration on a hanging. He walked to the front of the group while a docent put a noose around his neck to show what a hanging looks like.

OPA's Schulte told talk-show hosts on KFI Wednesday that the boy was not the only student to demonstrate the noose. By the end of the conversation, the hosts said they expected the teacher's reinstatement shortly.

However, the Oxford mom said that's not exactly how it went.

"My child was the only child in his classroom who did not volunteer but was called up."

She also believes putting a noose around her son is different.

"I don’t care that the other students did it. None of them are African-American. Their culture has not been victimized and traumatized … That’s disgusting," she said.

Oxford Prep's attorney, Keith Fink, believes the mom is aiming for a payday by trumping up the accusations. The school already has received a letter from the mom's attorney.

"The story is an outright fabrication of the mother and gross exaggeration and a race card play," Fink said. 

OPA's Schulte also told KFI the teachers did not know exactly what the demonstration was going to be.

But the OPA student’s mom finds that hard to believe, especially because Schultz grabbed the boy by the arm earlier in the day and pointed at the noose, promising "we'll deal with you at that later."

The mom also described two other incidents throughout the school year – her son’s first at the charter school – that could be read as racist.

In the first, the students were taking a class picture, the mom said. Schultz announced to the class that her son would not be visible in the photo because "he's as black as the wall."

In the second instance, Schultz pointed at a short, heavyset black man with hair and said that must be her son's father.

But Schultz has a second job at a gym where the boy’s father also works. She knows the dad – a 6-foot-3, thin and bald man, the mom said.

The mom said she wasn't aware of any of these instances until her son didn't want to go to school last week, and she was able to pry out of him what happened at Riley's Farm. Her two sons and other parents helped piece together the other incidents.

Parents thought the mom was already aware, she said.

"My son was a good student, a good soul, won the kindness award," she said. "He didn't even want to get Ms. Schultz into any kind of trouble."

Troubled by the experience, she contacted her pastor who lead her to OC Human Relations, which works to combat racism.

Together, they met with Principal Kyle Schuler, who seemed very indifferent to her son’s needs, the mom said. Schuler said he would investigate, but until then, he would back the teacher.

The worst part was that Schuler didn’t even ask her son how the incident made him feel, the mom said. So OC Human Relations CEO Rusty Kennedy asked him.

"'That incident made me feel worthless and that I do not matter,'" the mom relayed. "’The reason I didn't say anything because I didn’t think anyone cares.'"

The mother said Schuler's response proved her son right.

The next morning, the mother returned with the boy's father to again address the matter with Schuler. They got nowhere.

"I’m going to be backing my teacher," the mom said she was told.

That’s when she wrote a letter to the Capistrano Unified school board. Oxford is a charter of CUSD, but trustees do not have direct governance over the school.

Still, Superintendent Joseph Farley got back to the mom right away, and she credits his involvement with moving things along.

Shortly after, OPA Executive Director Sue Roche assured the mom that Schultz was put on leave.

Fink said the administration did everything right in this case. Roche has offered to pay for counseling and even if the teacher is cleared, she would not teach the boy.

Despite the teacher's leave of absence, her son has not gone back to school, the mom said. As of now, he's doing independent study.

She finds the situation even more disturbing than the highly publicized audiotape of Clippers owner Donald Sterling that has stirred up so much nationwide controversy, she said.

"It's disgusting, it's not an isolated incident," the mother said. "She should never teach anybody’s child."

OCMom2 July 11, 2014 at 03:53 PM
10 on just OPA since May and 3 in 2013 I got my that straight
OCMom2 July 11, 2014 at 03:56 PM
Actually the 3 in 2013 was someone else your posts just pertain to this subject
Jaimie Crowder July 12, 2014 at 03:26 PM
I think OCMOM2 sounds very self- absorbed. Rather than consider how the school admin practices have adversely affected many children; how can we learn from those mistakes and improve the running of the school, OCMOM2 wants commenters to just be quiet so that her child can continue to thrive. I really don't think you do care about the children that have left OPA. My hopes is that all parties concerned can see the bigger picture here. Do you know why we teach children US history? ( or history in general). because unless we are aware and learn from history, the same mistakes will continue to be made or in some cases we learn what works. I see nothing wrong with a forum which allows a form of freedom of speech. And this forum has helped bring light to many issues that have been sitting in our communities. And I thank you Penny that you have this blog. It appears to me that there are some post from former or current OPA community and it feels to me they would like to just have a voice. So let that voice continue to flow.
OCMom2 July 12, 2014 at 03:56 PM
Jamie you hit the nail right in the head I am very self-absorbed, after all I live in south county and am a stepford mindless zombie.
OCMom2 July 12, 2014 at 03:56 PM
Opps with teal colored lens


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »